C2C success comes from identifying quarterbacks with the right blend of talent, opportunity, and system fit. You want guys who can light up the scoreboard now and develop into future NFL starters. With Superflex and 2QB formats, nailing your QB picks is the fastest way to build a contender. This list is your blueprint for dominating 2025 drafts and stacking wins for seasons to come.

1. Arch Manning, Texas (Sophomore)

• Why #1: Manning embodies the C2C dream: elite CFF upside in a powerhouse offense coupled with generational devy value. He possesses the total package – NFL-caliber arm talent, advanced pocket presence, underrated mobility (4.62 speed), and the poise of a veteran. Stepping into the starting role for an SEC-title-contending Texas team loaded with weapons (Wingo, Moore Jr.) and backed by a strong defense, Manning is primed for a monster season.
• Metrics (2024 Limited Action): 67% Comp, 969 Yds, 9 TD, 2 INT in 8 games (2 starts). Dual-threat capability showcased (75+ yd pass TD, 65+ yd rush TD).
• System Context: Steve Sarkisian’s high-octane, pro-style offense perfectly suits Manning’s strengths. Expect heavy volume, aggressive downfield passing, and RPO elements leveraging his athleticism. The system has produced elite fantasy QBs and NFL draft picks.
• Schedule Notes: The SEC gauntlet awaits, but it provides massive stages (opener @ Ohio State) for huge performances. The defense ensures he won’t always need 40 points to win, but the offense will be asked to carry significant weight.
• CFF/Devy Impact: CFF: Projected top-3 scorer. High-volume passing + rushing upside = weekly ceiling games. Devy: The #1 devy QB asset. Franchise-altering NFL prospect with legitimate top overall pick potential in 2026/2027.

2. DJ Lagway, Florida (Sophomore)

• Why #2: Lagway is Manning’s closest rival, boasting elite dual-threat ability in a system designed for his talents. His cannon arm and legit 4.4 speed create a fantasy cheat code. After a strong finish to 2024 (6-1 as starter, wins over LSU/Ole Miss), he enters 2025 healthy, in command of Billy Napier’s offense, and surrounded by a solid supporting cast (4 OL starters back, RB Baugh).
• Metrics (2024): 59.9% Comp, 1915 Yds, 12 TD, 9 INT, 10.0 YPA (2nd SEC). Rushing limited post-injury (101 yds), but mobility is a core trait.
• System Context: Napier’s offense maximizes QB rushing and vertical shots. Lagway’s unique blend of size (6’3″, 240) and speed makes him a nightmare in this scheme. Expect heavy RPO usage and designed runs.
• Schedule Notes: Manageable start before SEC tests ramp up (@ LSU Sept. 13th). A full offseason as the clear starter is invaluable.
• CFF/Devy Impact: CFF: Elite dual-threat potential = Top 5 CFF QB ceiling. Rushing floor provides safety. Devy: Top-tier devy asset. Prototype modern NFL QB with Round 1 pedigree. 2027 draft target.

3. Bryce Underwood, Michigan (Freshman)

• Why #3: The #1 overall recruit (2025) possesses rare tools: prototypical size (6’4″, 215), an elite arm, and improved mobility. While a true freshman, his talent is too immense to ignore. An early enrollee, he’s competing immediately in an offense transitioning post-Harbaugh but retaining a strong run game and O-line.
• Metrics (HS Sr.): 71.8% Comp, 2509 Yds, 32 TD, 6 INT; 600+ Rush Yds, 6 TD. 48+ career starts, 165+ total TDs.
• System Context: Sherrone Moore’s offense will lean on the run game initially, providing a softer landing. Expect evolution to leverage Underwood’s arm talent as he acclimates. The system won’t ask him to do everything alone early.
• Schedule Notes: Early tests will reveal his readiness. The Big Ten schedule is always defensively challenging.
• CFF/Devy Impact: CFF: High-risk, stratospheric-reward. If he starts early, dual-threat ability offers massive upside. Expect inconsistency. Devy: The ultimate devy gem. Franchise QB potential. Draft him for 2026/2027 and be patient. Must-have in devy drafts.

4. Cade Klubnik, Clemson (Senior)

• Why #4: Klubnik delivers proven high-level CFF production and rising devy stock. Coming off a breakout 2024 (3,639 Yds, 36 Pass TD, 463 Rush Yds, 7 Rush TD), he returns as the unquestioned leader in Garrett Riley’s QB-friendly system behind a veteran O-line (4 starters back).
• Metrics (2024): 63.4% Comp, 3639 Yds, 36 TD, 6 INT; 463 Rush Yds, 7 TD. Marked improvement in decision-making.
• System Context: Riley’s offense is tailored for QB success. Expect heavy RPOs, play-action, and designed concepts to get playmakers in space. Klubnik’s experience and improved rushing make him a perfect fit.
• Schedule Notes: Huge opening test vs. LSU (Aug 30) sets the tone. ACC schedule offers consistent production opportunities, but road tests @ UNC, @ Louisville, @ SCar loom.
• CFF/Devy Impact: CFF: High-floor, high-ceiling QB1. Dual-threat production in an efficient offense. Safe early pick. Devy: Solidifying as a potential 2026 NFL Draft riser (Day 2 projection). Continued growth could push him into Round 1 conversation.

5. Keelon Russell, Alabama (Freshman)

• Why #5: The Gatorade National POY (#2 overall recruit) steps into Kalen DeBoer’s quarterback-friendly offense. Russell boasts a “flamethrower” arm, impressive mobility, and advanced feel. While a true freshman, his talent and the system’s track record (Penix Jr.) create immense upside.
• Metrics (HS Sr.): 69.4% Comp, 4177 Yds, 55 TD, 5 INT. Elite production against top Texas HS competition.
• System Context: DeBoer’s offense is a dream for talented QBs – quick-game, RPOs, and aggressive downfield shots. Russell’s skillset aligns perfectly. He’s the favorite in a QB competition to start Day 1.
• Schedule Notes: Trial by fire: opener @ Florida State (Aug 30), @ Georgia late Sept. The brutal SEC schedule demands rapid maturation.
• CFF/Devy Impact: CFF: High-upside gamble. If he wins the job, the system offers massive passing TD potential. Expect rookie bumps. Devy: Elite devy prospect. Ideal system fit boosts his already sky-high NFL potential.

6. Sam Leavitt, Arizona State (Sophomore)

• Why #6: Leavitt is a prime CFF breakout candidate. His dual-threat skills are perfectly suited for Kenny Dillingham’s up-tempo, innovative offense. Entering his second year in the system, expect a significant leap in production and comfort.
• Metrics: 61.7% Comp, 2,885 Yds, 24 TD, 6 INT; 443 Rush Yds, 5 TD.
• System Context: Dillingham’s scheme prioritizes pace, creates mismatches, and heavily features QB rushing via designed runs and scrambles. Leavitt’s mobility is his calling card here.
• Schedule Notes: Navigating the Big 12 in Year 2 offers opportunities (Baylor, TTU, Houston, CU).
• CFF/Devy Impact: CFF: Target him as a high-upside QB2 with weekly QB1 potential thanks to rushing volume. Ideal for formats rewarding QB rushing. Devy: Climbing devy sleeper. Strong 2025 could make him a hot 2027 NFL Draft name. Monitor development.

7. LaNorris Sellers, South Carolina (RS Sophomore)

• Why #7: Sellers is a CFF beast due to his elite rushing ability (prototypical size/speed combo). His fantasy floor comes from designed runs and scrambles. The key for his ceiling and devy value is continued growth as a passer.
• Metrics: 65.6% Comp, 2,534 Yds, 18 TD, 7 INT; 674 Rush Yds, 7 TD.
• System Context: Shane Beamer’s offense will lean heavily on Sellers’ legs via option and designed QB runs. The passing game needs development around him and from him to unlock higher upside.
• Schedule Notes: The SEC schedule is relentless. Performance against elite defenses (LSU, Bama, Oklahoma, Clemson) will define his season and evaluation.
• CFF/Devy Impact: CFF: High rushing floor provides weekly starter value. If passing improves, top-5 CFF QB potential exists. Devy: Speculative but high-upside. NFL potential hinges entirely on proving he can be a competent, consistent passer. Worth a stash.

8. Drew Allar, Penn State (Senior)

• Why #8: Allar offers CFF consistency and intriguing NFL traits. He improved significantly in 2024 (66.5% Comp, 3,327 Yds, 24 Pass TD, 302 Rush Yds, 6 Rush TD) and boasts exceptional ball security (53 TD / 10 INT career). Big frame (6’5″, 235), strong arm.
• Metrics (2024): 66.5% Comp, 3327 Yds, 24 TD, 8 INT; 302 Rush Yds, 6 TD. Elite TD/INT ratio.
• System Context: Andy Kotelnicki’s offense leverages Allar’s arm and improved mobility. A strong run game (Singleton/Allen) and defense provide stability, sometimes limiting pure volume.
• Schedule Notes: Big Ten schedule demands proving he can win big games consistently (Ohio State, USC). NFL scouts are watching these performances closely.
• CFF/Devy Impact: CFF: High-floor QB1/2. Efficiency and rushing TDs provide solid points. Less likely for massive 40-point weeks. Devy: Projected 2026 NFL Draft pick (potential Round 1, needs big-game performances). Solid devy hold.

9. John Mateer, Oklahoma (Redshirt Junior)

• Why #9: Mateer is a CFF machine. His transfer to Oklahoma after a historic 2024 at Washington State (3,139 Pass Yds, 29 Pass TD, 826 Rush Yds, 15 Rush TD) places him in another QB-friendly system. His elite dual-threat production is proven and projectable.
• Metrics (2024 – WSU): 64.6% Comp, 3139 Yds, 29 TD, 7 INT; 826 Rush Yds, 15 TD (Led FBS with 44 Total TDs).
• System Context: Brent Venables’ offense at Oklahoma thrives with mobile QBs. Expect Mateer’s rushing volume and TD potential to remain extremely high in this scheme.
• Schedule Notes: Welcome to the SEC. The schedule is brutal (Alabama, LSU, Texas, Tennessee, Missouri). Production might be harder-earned, but volume should still be significant.
• CFF/Devy Impact: CFF: Must-have target. Elite rushing production at QB is gold. Top 5 CFF QB potential even with tougher schedule. Devy: High-upside sleeper. If he thrives in the SEC, his 2027 NFL Draft stock will soar. Fantastic devy value pick.

10. Garrett Nussmeier, LSU (Senior)

• Why #10: Nussmeier is the CFF volume king. As LSU’s entrenched starter in their pass-happy offense, he’s a lock for massive passing numbers (4,052 Yds, 29 TD in 2024). He returns with a loaded WR corps (Anderson, Brown, top recruits).
• Metrics (2024): 64.2% Comp, 4052 Yds (5th in FBS), 29 TD, 12 INT.
• System Context: LSU’s system is built to throw early and often. Nussmeier excels with quick processing, reading progressions, and delivering with touch. Expect 35+ attempts per game consistently.
• Schedule Notes: Gauntlet: at Clemson, at Bama, at Oklahoma. Shootouts are likely, meaning huge volume and fantasy points, but also potential for turnovers against elite defenses.
• CFF/Devy Impact: CFF: High-volume QB1. The safest bet for 300+ yard games. Top 8 CFF QB. Devy: Solid NFL prospect (Day 3 projection – Rds 4/5). High football IQ and touch, lacks elite physical traits. Hold for production, but not a cornerstone devy asset.

System + Opportunity > Talent alone. Track camp battles (especially Russell/Bama), monitor health (Lagway), and watch how offenses evolve around these talents. This Top 10 provides the blueprint; now go execute your draft and dominate your C2C leagues in 2025 and beyond.

FAQ

Q1: Why focus on these 10 QBs?
They combine immediate CFF production (points per game) with long-term Devy value—talent + opportunity + scheme fit.

Q2: How to prioritize rookies vs. proven vets?
Balance high-ceiling freshmen (Underwood, Russell) with high-floor upperclassmen (Klubnik, Nussmeier). Volume + system fit = safety.

Q3: What formats benefit most?
Superflex & 2QB formats—where QB scarcity and dual-threat upside multiply returns.

Q4: When should I trade for QBs?
If you’re thin at QB1/2, target managers overloaded with near-NFL QBs; swap surplus picks or veterans for future QB assets.

Q5: How often should I revisit these rankings?
Monitor spring camp (May–June), fall camp (July–August), and injury reports (late August). ADP and depth charts shift rapidly.