Jonathan James McCarthy, born January 20, 2003, is an American Football Quarterback. He played a key role in Michigan’s 2024 national championship win. McCarthy transferred to IMG Academy in 2020 during his senior year from Nazareth Academy due to the cancellation of their football season amid the COVID-19 pandemic.
In the 2021 season, McCarthy debuted for Michigan with a notable 69-yard touchdown pass. He played in 11 games, accumulating 516 yards, five touchdowns, and two interceptions. In the 2022 season, McCarthy secured the starting quarterback role after an impressive performance against Hawaii, leading the Wolverines to a 42–0 halftime lead. Throughout the season, he maintained consistency with notable performances.
The 2023 season showcased McCarthy’s career-best passing game against East Carolina with 280 yards and three touchdowns. In the Rose Bowl against Alabama, he earned the Offensive MVP title with 221 yards and three touchdowns. The pinnacle of McCarthy’s college career came in the College Football Playoff National Championship against Washington, where he led Michigan to a 34–13 victory.
Michigan’s junior QB, J.J. McCarthy, faces a pivotal decision in the 2024 NFL Draft or another year in college. With an impressive record of 25 wins and 1 loss, McCarthy’s stats include over 2,600 passing yards, 19 TDs, and minimal interceptions. Known for his dual-threat capability, McCarthy’s versatility makes him a standout in any offensive scheme. Despite concerns about his exposure to a pass-heavy offense at Michigan, McCarthy’s arm strength and accuracy position him as a top QB prospect. However, questions persist about his adaptation to the NFL style, emphasizing the need for more reps in high-pressure passing situations.
Pros
- McCarthy displays evident arm talent, delivering precise throws in tight spaces, reminiscent of clutch moments against Ohio State.
- Despite a run-heavy offense, he consistently takes control of games, registering 2,719 yards and 22 touchdowns in a season.
- Agile in the pocket, McCarthy demonstrates deep ball accuracy, particularly highlighted against Purdue in tight coverage.
- With a strong pocket presence, effective play-action, and consistent mechanics, McCarthy’s frame and on-field performance indicate significant potential for development at the next level.
Cons
- McCarthy, despite a strong arm, struggles with inconsistent ball placement.
- When throwing deep, he faces challenges with touch and loft.
- His dropbacks lack crispness and rhythm.
- Physique-wise, his wiry frame raises concerns about handling NFL-caliber hits, especially in the tackle box or on scrambles.
- McCarthy’s pocket presence needs refinement; while mobile, he tends to escape clean pockets rather than navigating with poise.
